Most of the following eight arguments came from a contemporary moral issues class that i taught at the university of wisconsinmadison in the fall of 1995. I asked the students to give me their best arguments in favor of. When you flip through eating animals, written by the author of everything is illuminated and extremely loud and incredibly close, you can almost see jonathan safran foers tears dried on the pages. Eight arguments in favor of eating meat and objections thereto. For more than two decades his popular and compelling stories appeared in the times, where he was ultimately the lead food writer for the sunday magazine and became the countrys first food. The meat fix is the story of how eating meat again after twentysix vegetarian years changed john. Also, i understood that eating processed lunchmeat daily adds significant risk to colon cancer and other problems. He is not a scientist and this is not your standard diet book. This is an emotional account of safran foers journey away from meateating, a decision that was spurred by becoming a husband and father. Rising global meat consumption will devastate environment. Containing virtually a whos who of philosophers, social critics, environmentalists, feminists, and religious scholars who have participated in the. You mentioned one nonenvironmental impact as being to do with labour and the first book that youve chosen, the jungle by upton sinclair 1906a novel that portrays the working conditions of those in the meat packing industry at the turn of the twentieth centurydeals with this labour question. Yet its message should not undermine hans achievement as a writer.
The strange, disquieting, and sometimes delicious story of humanitys love affair with meat. Thats a good start because stewing produces fewer potentially carcinogenic compounds than broiling. Eating animals explores the various ways we justify our meat habit. Beef liver and clams are the best sources of vitamin b12, nih cites again. I couldnt stand the choices of lunch meat available they tasted like boiled meat, briny salt and chemicals, but were otherwise tasteless and bland. Your meateating friends want one of these 10 vegan books. The most important books out there about meat, meateating, and vegetarian diet. Top books about meateating and vegetarianism 18 books. Adams, deanne curtin, and val plumwood, among other outstanding advocates, debate the ethics of eating meat in connection with feminism, environmentalism, and multiculturalism. Containing virtually a whos who of philosophers, social critics, environmentalists, feminists, and religious scholars who have participated in the vegetarianism debate over the past quarter century, this outstanding anthology of expert articles, most of them new, provides the latest thinking on a. There are many arguments in favor of eating meat, from cultural tradition to natural nutrition, so weve decided to take a deeper look at the top 3 most common arguments in favor of eating meat. And keep in mind that eating a sixounce steak is not the same as eating a 12ounce steak. For most, the biggest attachment to meat is that its part of their.
This is an emotional account of safran foers journey away from meat eating, a decision that was spurred by becoming a husband and father. He is the author of twelve books, including the authoritative and internationally bestselling real food companion and the gourmet farmer deli book, as well as. Pick one you believe will resonate most, and casually offer the book to the stubborn meat eater in your life. It touches on immigration, and class, and many issues beyond that of eating meat. One study found that approximately 60% of contemporary professional ethicists consider it morally bad to eat meat from mammals. The question of whether it is right to eat animal flesh is among the most prominent topics in food. There is a vast mythology surrounding meat, but all the myths are in one way or another related to what i refer to as the three ns of justification. The ethical case against eating animal produce once seemed clear. The best books on eating meat five books expert recommendations. Guide to meat identification, fabrication, and utilization is the definitive guide to purchasing and fabricating meat cuts for professional chefs, foodservice personnel, culinarians, and food enthusiasts. The three ns have been invoked to justify all exploitative systems, from african slavery to the nazi holocaust. Mark bittman is the author of thirty acclaimed books, including the how to cook everything series, the awardwinning food matters, and the new yorktimes numberone bestseller, vb6. Waring pro offers an easy alternative to slicing food by hand.
Eating meat seven times a week is not the same as eating it four times. With relationships such as these, sometimes we need to let a third party do the convincing, which is why weve compiled a list of 10 books that make the most compelling arguments for a plantbased diet. Written by bestselling author jonathan safran foer, this book delves into the cultural, social and economic roots of meateating. The vegetarian is a book about the failures of language and the mysteries of the physical. Like its antiprotagonist, the vegetarian whispers so clearly, it can be heard across the room, insistently and with devastating, quiet violence. Eating meat is part of my culture despite the rise in plant based diets, about 96% of the world still eats meat. Analysis suggests eating of meat will climb steeply and play significant role in increasing carbon emissions and reducing biodiversity. I asked the students to give me their best arguments in favor of eating meat, and these are the results. Ethologist jane goodall stated in the 2009 book the inner world of farm animals that. But recent research suggests vitamins might be useless. The risks associated with following a vegetarian diet surround deficiencies in certain vitamins and minerals, like vitamin b12, and omega3 fatty acids.
1343 1202 1343 900 1344 706 632 27 140 1562 130 1335 1082 305 812 1239 787 1217 1026 1179 413 1428 394 1546 1363 1616 294 926 1285 481 420 1330 326 1226 932 559 1556 1168 890 615 1052 98 1475 1464 875 1077